Accountant Michael Scott, his wife and their two kids have been living
in their first home since 1999, but recently became concerned that it's in
a high-risk flood zone in a low-lying area along the east side of the San
Francisco Bay.
The area has never flooded due to natural causes, Scott said, but his
worry stems from scientific global warming predictions that his San
Leandro, CA, home, just 75 feet from Estudillo Creek, could be inundated
within 50 years -- if not sooner -- along with dozens of other homes in
coastal communities nationwide.
To ease his concerns he's rationalized that by the time global warming
creates a worst-case scenario, if it does, his kids will be grown, the
house paid off and he'll have plenty of time to flee to higher ground
before rising sea levels force him out.
"We decided we like the community here and there's always a chance
that the predictions are wrong or that they will send up a red flag and
people will take action. It doesn't seem like anything is going to happen
for at least 10 years or more," he says.
He hopes.
But what if Scott had to shop for a home today?
"If we were looking for a home, would we move here now? No.
Probably not," he concedes.
Global warming is beginning to impact the choices some people make
about where to buy a home.
Chances are, only a tiny fraction of home buyers like Scott actually
give a toastier planet a second thought when they consider a home
purchase.
But low-lying areas and arid, drought-prone regions and others which
are likely to first feel the effects of global warming are certainly
putting new meaning into the phrase, "Location. Location.
Location."
"Everybody is not going to pick up and move today, but with 15 to
20 percent of the population moving every year, there are a growing number
of people beginning to ask this question," said John McIlwain, an
Urban Land Institute senior resident fellow who holds the institute's J.
Ronald Terwilliger Chair for Housing.
"People aren't going to sit there and ask, 'Should I move?', but
when they have decided to move they will think about where they should
move," said McIlwain.
Impact of Global Warming
Global warming refers to a recent pattern of accelerated increases in
Earth temperatures that are disrupting meteorological patterns and
planetary conditions that sustain human life.
Nonbelievers abound, but most climate scientists, including those with National
Aeronautics Space Administration (NASA); the National
Academy of Sciences (NAS); and the World
Meteorological Organization all say the planet is nearing a state of
emergency and humans are helping push that state to a reality.
Carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels adds to the heat trapped in
the atmosphere, the so-called "greenhouse effect," and that's
expanding desert regions, raising temperatures, melting glaciers and ice
caps and swelling sea levels at rates more perceptible and measurable than
ever.
Scientists say the Earth has the highest levels of carbon dioxide in
more than 400,000 years and the 10 hottest years on record since
measurements were first recorded 125 years ago all have occurred since
1990.
In addition to burning fossil fuels, another global warming
contributing factor is the "heat island" created by replacing
natural cooling vegetation with large new home and commercial developments
and with paved open space, according to the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency. The urban and suburban heat islands
can produce temperatures 2 to 10 degrees hotter than nearby rural areas
and aggravate smog, which worsens in hot weather, the EPA says.
Arthur
H. Rosenfeld, a member of the California Energy Commission, says
temperatures in the Los Angeles area have increased 7 degrees since 1940.
Some major cities, including Chicago, New York and Boston have taken to
landscaping the rooftops of buildings to help offset the effect, but they
could be too late.
How Hot Is It?
This year, ironically, just before a heat wave swept the nation,
killing people in record numbers, the United Nations Environment Programme
(UNEP) examining climate
change in the desert, produced "Global
Deserts Outlook". The report says the deserts of the world are
getting hotter and the heat is spreading the desert and its ecosystem
beyond existing desert borders.
Call it desert sprawl.
That trend and other climatic changes are beginning to negate
predictable temperate weather patterns that generate demand and added
property value. As excessive heat and increased smog become intolerable
for some home buyers, the reduced demand could be a telling market factor.
"I grew up in Orange County. I've been there for 47 years and we
used to have predictable weather patterns -- 85 in the summer and chilly
in the winter and it was constant. A few weeks ago it was 115 degrees (F)
in Diamond Bar," said celebrity appraiser Randall Bell of Anderson
& Sanders LLC of Laguna Beach, CA.
Bell's work is the economic impact of detrimental conditions, such as
environmental issues, floods, earthquakes and tornadoes as well as
construction defects, soil problems, market cycles and more, including
crimes and other stigmas associated with properties. Bell developed the
noted "Bell Chart" a matrix of 10 categories, including
"Natural Conditions" and their impact on the value of property.
His expertise makes him the Appraisal
Institute's designated expert on the impact of global warming on
housing values.
"The weather has become a wild card. Good weather is no longer
guaranteed. I don't know if its measurable (in terms of an impact on
values). There have been no formal studies. My only take on it is there is
no place you can move in the U.S. with the assumption of good
weather," Bell said.
When it comes to global warming weather, some low-lying coastal regions
have already begun to feel the effects, according to scientists who this
year said more
hurricanes and more intense hurricanes in 2005 were a direct result of
global warming.
A home's location right now can mean greater insurance costs, and
higher insurance costs already make or break deals. Lenders won't sign off
at closing if the homeowner can't obtain adequate coverage. Homes are less
attractive as an investment if they come with prohibitively high insurance
costs, limited coverage or coverage of last resort.